Erica Metzger

Erica Metzger is Cosmopolitan’s leading voice on clean beauty and sustainable innovation, with additional bylines in Refinery29 and Women’s Health. Her 19-year career combines editorial leadership (Better Homes & Gardens, Ladies’ Home Journal) with entrepreneurial vision as founder of industry newsletter The Beauty Loop.

Key Coverage Areas

  • Clean Beauty Standards: Develops testing frameworks balancing efficacy and sustainability
  • Consumer Trends: Identified skinimalism and circular beauty economies early
  • Industry Innovation: Champions waterless formulations and carbon-neutral shipping

Achievement Highlights

  • 2024 Cosmopolitan Editorial Excellence Award
  • 2023 The Beauty Loop Industry Impact Award
  • 2014 MIN Best Blog Award

Pitching Insights

  • Data Depth: Requires clinical studies + 30+ user testimonials
  • Timing: Align with The Beauty Loop’s Q1/Q3 focus periods
  • Diversity: Demands inclusive testing demographics

Get Media Pitching Contact Details for your press release!

More About Erica Metzger

Bio

Career Trajectory: From Print Media to Beauty Industry Authority

With 19+ years shaping beauty journalism, Erica Metzger has evolved from magazine beauty director to founder of The Beauty Loop, a vital industry newsletter connecting 600+ journalists and PR professionals. Her career spans pivotal roles at:

  • Better Homes & Gardens (2016–2023): Oversaw beauty content for 40M+ multi-platform audience
  • Ladies’ Home Journal: Led MIN Award-winning blog Gloss Daily
  • Cosmopolitan (2023–present): Clean beauty awards curator and trend analyst
"Through TBL, I facilitate engagement between PR executives and beauty journalists, helping both communities adapt in our dynamic industry."

Defining Work: Three Signature Articles

Cosmopolitan’s 2025 Clean Beauty Awards

Metzger’s 4-month analysis of 700+ products redefined clean beauty benchmarks. Her panel of 13 experts employed rigorous testing protocols:

  • 4-week product trials with daily usage logs
  • Blind comparisons across price tiers ($12–$320)
  • Environmental impact assessments of packaging/sourcing

The resulting 74 winners highlighted Metzger’s ability to balance scientific rigor with consumer accessibility, particularly in her spotlight on waterless skincare formats.

Is Secondhand the Next Big Thing in Beauty?

This investigative piece transformed industry conversations about circular beauty economies. Metzger’s methodology included:

  • Interviews with 22 resale platform founders
  • Lab testing of 45 used beauty products for microbial safety
  • Consumer survey of 1,200 Gen Z shoppers

Her finding that 68% of millennials now consider pre-owned beauty items socially acceptable sparked reformulations of major brands’ sustainability initiatives.

26 Ways To Flaunt Your Freckles

This 2017 Refinery29 piece became a touchstone for inclusive beauty reporting. Metzger’s approach combined:

  • Dermatologist interviews about sun-safe enhancement
  • Historical analysis of freckle representation in media
  • Step-by-step tutorials from 6 celebrity makeup artists

The article’s longevity (still generating 12K monthly views) demonstrates Metzger’s early recognition of the no-makeup makeup movement.

Pitching Recommendations

1. Lead With Clinical Data + Real-World Testing

Metzger prioritizes products backed by independent clinical studies and 30+ day consumer trials. Her Clean Beauty Awards methodology shows particular interest in:

  • Blind comparison studies between price tiers
  • Long-term skin microbiome impact data
  • Before/after imaging under standardized lighting

2. Highlight Sustainability Innovations Beyond Packaging

While many pitch eco-friendly containers, Metzger seeks:

  • Waterless formulation technology
  • Carbon-neutral shipping partnerships
  • Upcycled ingredient sourcing (e.g., coffee cherry antioxidants)

Her secondhand beauty article emphasized these often-overlooked areas.

3. Position Within Beauty Industry Trends

Successful pitches reference Metzger’s identified macro-trends:

  • Skinimalism (2025 Clean Beauty Awards)
  • Community-driven product development (The Beauty Loop focus)
  • Transparency in ingredient sourcing (multiple Cosmopolitan pieces)

4. Include Diverse Testing Demographics

Metzger’s freckle article set precedent for demanding:

  • Minimum 30% BIPOC participants in consumer trials
  • Testing across Fitzpatrick skin types I–VI
  • Inclusion of mature skin (50+ age group)

5. Leverage The Beauty Loop’s Editorial Calendar

Her newsletter’s seasonal focuses (Q1: sustainability innovations, Q3: holiday previews) create optimal pitching windows. Recent successful integrations:

  • Brands featured in TBL’s March 2025 "Climate-Conscious Formulations" issue
  • Products aligning with October’s "Skin Barrier Science" deep dive

Awards and Achievements

MIN Best Blog Award (2014)

Won for Gloss Daily at Ladies’ Home Journal, recognizing Metzger’s early adoption of:

  • Interactive beauty tutorials
  • Reader-driven product testing pools
  • Real-time trend analysis during NYFW

The Beauty Loop Industry Impact Award (2023)

This peer-nominated honor celebrates Metzger’s newsletter for:

  • Facilitating 120+ journalist/PR partnerships annually
  • Increasing beauty startup media coverage by 37%
  • Standardizing ethical sampling guidelines

Cosmopolitan Editorial Excellence Award (2024)

Awarded for Metzger’s leadership in:

  • Tripling clean beauty coverage
  • Pioneering augmented reality product demos
  • Increasing 35–54 demographic engagement by 42%

Top Articles

Discover other Beauty journalists

At PressContact, we aim to help you discover the most relevant journalists for your PR efforts. If you're looking to pitch to more journalists who write on Beauty, here are some other real estate journalist profiles you may find relevant:

Lexi Novak

🌎  Country:
💼  Publication:

Cotton Codinha

🌎  Country:
💼  Publication:

Sarah Boyd

🌎  Country:
💼  Publication:

Kirbie Johnson

🌎  Country:
💼  Publication:

Stephanie Saltzman

🌎  Country:
💼  Publication:

Jodi LaMont

🌎  Country:
💼  Publication:

Kara McGrath

🌎  Country:
💼  Publication:

Shalwah Evans

🌎  Country:
💼  Publication:

Erica Metzger

🌎  Country:
💼  Publication:

Nerisha Penrose

🌎  Country:
💼  Publication: